Shin Splints: What the Research Says About Medial Tibial Stress Syndrome, Diagnosis and Recovery
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
Key Takeaways
- Shin splints is the common name for medial tibial stress syndrome (MTSS), which affects 5%–35% of runners.[1]
- Female sex, increased weight, higher navicular drop, previous running injury, and greater hip external rotation with the hip flexed have been identified as risk factors in a meta-analysis.[2]
- In a reliability study, two clinicians using history and physical examination agreed almost perfectly on whether an athlete had MTSS.[3]
- A review of conservative treatment notes that imaging is usually not needed to diagnose MTSS, although further imaging or work-up may be needed to rule out a stress fracture.[4]
- According to the same review, most of the literature supports rest as the key treatment in the acute phase of MTSS.[4]
- A systematic review found no treatment study free enough from bias to support a recommendation; of the treatments examined, shockwave therapy (ESWT) looked the most promising.[5]
- In my clinical experience, separating shin splints from a bony stress injury is the hardest diagnostic question; the history carries a lot of weight, and MRI is the precise tool when it is available.
- In my practice, many recreational runners find it hard to switch to another sport, and a cycle of resting, doing some rehabilitation and returning to the same sport tends, in my experience, to make the condition chronic.
Introduction: Shin Splints
Few running complaints are as familiar as shin splints. Medial tibial stress syndrome (MTSS), the medical name for the condition, affects 5%–35% of runners.[1] The incidence of MTSS is reported as being between 4% and 35% in military personnel and athletes.[6] In a systematic review of running-related injuries, medial tibial stress syndrome had an incidence ranging from 13.6% to 20.0% and a prevalence of 9.5%.[7]
Patients with shin pain come to my clinic every now and then. In my experience, the most difficult differential diagnostic question is separating a potential bony stress injury from ordinary shin splints, and it is not always simple.
As a physician and a former world champion in Taekwon-Do, I look at shin pain from both a clinical and an athletic perspective. This article covers what shin splints actually is, who gets it, how it is diagnosed, how it differs from a tibial stress fracture, and what the treatment studies have — and have not — shown.
What Is Actually Hurting in Shin Splints?
A critical review defines the condition as exercise-related pain along the posteromedial border of the tibia, with tenderness on palpation over a length of at least 5 cm.[6] Historical names for MTSS include “shin splints”, medial tibial syndrome, tibial stress syndrome and soleus syndrome.[2]
For a long time, the pain was explained as inflammation of the bone lining (periostitis) caused by muscle traction. The same review concluded that histological studies do not support traction-related periostitis as the cause; instead, in the authors’ interpretation, MTSS reflects bone resorption in the tibial cortex that outpaces new bone formation.[6]
Shin Splints Risk Factors: Who Gets It?
Two meta-analyses have pooled the risk factor data.
In runners, a meta-analysis of ten papers found a statistically significant association with MTSS for:[1]
- increased hip external rotation in males (SMD 0.67, 95% CI 0.29–1.04)
- prior use of orthotics (RR 2.31, 95% CI 1.56–3.43)
- fewer years of running experience (SMD −0.74, 95% CI −1.26 to −0.23)
- female gender (RR 1.71, 95% CI 1.15–2.54)
- previous history of MTSS (RR 3.74, 95% CI 1.17–11.91)
- increased body mass index (SMD 0.24, 95% CI 0.08–0.41)
- navicular drop (SMD 0.26, 95% CI 0.02–0.50) and navicular drop >10 mm (RR 1.99, 95% CI 1.00–3.96)
A broader meta-analysis in active individuals concluded that female sex, increased weight, higher navicular drop, previous running injury, and greater hip external rotation with the hip in flexion are risk factors for the development of MTSS.[2] In that review, female sex had an odds ratio of 2.35 (95% CI 1.58–3.50) and previous running injury an odds ratio of 2.18 (95% CI 1.00–4.72).[2]
Navicular drop is a measure of how much the arch collapses when standing — a proxy for foot pronation. The link with prior orthotic use is an association and does not show that orthotics cause MTSS.
How Shin Splints Is Diagnosed
In a multi-centre reliability study in the Netherlands, athletes with non-traumatic lower leg pain were assessed for having MTSS by two clinicians. The inter-rater reliability was almost perfect; k=0.89 (95% CI 0.74 to 1.00).[3] The authors concluded that MTSS can be diagnosed reliably in the clinic with history and physical examination; the study measured agreement between clinicians.[3]
The same study found that 11 of the 34 athletes with MTSS (32%) also had another lower leg injury at the same time.[3] Shin pain is not always one problem.
In my practice, the history plays a large role. Many of my patients describe a longer period of loading or increased loading. A fairly typical story is that the shins become sore after training, usually after a run, stay sore for a few days and then settle a little, but never settle completely. Some of them have been taking anti-inflammatory painkillers, which in my experience help only temporarily. With a bony stress injury, the background I see is more often a march, a marathon, a half-marathon, an ultramarathon or some other unusually long effort; during military marches I see this every now and then.
Clinically, I find the two very hard to tell apart, because in both the tibial bone is usually tender. In my experience, shin splints tends to hurt more around the area where the muscles attach to the tibia, whereas a bony stress injury may also be tender over an area where no muscle fascia covers the bone. This is a very non-specific marker, and in my view it is neither diagnostically definitive nor reliable, but in the overall assessment it may add something to my thinking. Sometimes the two pictures also appear at the same time.
Shin Splints or a Stress Fracture?
According to a review of conservative treatment, imaging is usually not needed to diagnose MTSS, but some patients may need further imaging or work-up to rule out stress fractures.[4] If a patient does not improve with conservative management, plain radiographs may be considered, although X-rays are usually negative in the first 2–3 weeks after the injury begins.[4] Bone scans were long the reference standard for stress fractures, but MRI has now often taken their place.[4]
The same review reports that females have a 1.5 to 3.5 times higher risk of progressing to stress fractures.[4] It also notes that clinicians should keep a high index of suspicion for eating disorders and nutritional deficiencies.[4]
In my experience, a bony stress injury usually cannot be seen on a fresh X-ray, because the changes take time to develop, and spotting them takes a careful eye from the clinician or radiologist. The precise diagnostic tool is MRI, but it is not always available: in my practice, that depends on whether the patient has insurance or good occupational health coverage. Athletes are often imaged with MRI at a fairly early stage, because they often have insurance or want the imaging themselves, and some pay for it to rule things out. In my view, the criteria for imaging are in principle the same as for sedentary patients, and with many of my patients who are not athletes, we have stayed on watchful follow-up.
Shin Splints Treatment: What Studies Have Tested
This is the section where honesty matters most. In a 2013 systematic review of MTSS treatment, every randomized trial was judged to be at high risk of bias, and both non-randomized trials were rated as poor quality.[5] The authors concluded that no study was free enough from methodological bias to support recommending any of the treatments tested.[5] An earlier critical review noted that in the three randomized treatment trials available at the time, rest performed as well as any intervention.[6]
Rest and Load Reduction
A review of conservative treatment states that most of the literature supports rest as the key treatment in the acute phase.[4] It adds that some patients may need relative rest and time away from sport for 2 to 6 weeks.[4] According to the review, cutting weekly running distance, frequency and intensity by 50% will likely improve symptoms without stopping completely, and athletes can cross-train with other low-impact exercise during this period.[4] These are practical suggestions from a narrative review, not durations or load reductions tested in randomized trials.
Graded Running, Calf Exercises and Compression
In a randomized trial of 74 athletes, one group performed a graded running program, a second added stretching and strengthening exercises for the calves, and a third added a sports compression stocking.[8] Time to complete a running program and general satisfaction with the treatment were not significantly different between the three treatment groups.[8] Of the 74 athletes, 14 did not complete the study due to a lack of progress (18.9%).[8]
Shockwave Therapy
Of the treatments examined in the systematic review, ESWT looked the most promising.[5] In a prospective controlled study of 42 athletes, one group did a graded running programme and the other the same programme plus focused shockwave therapy (five sessions in 9 weeks).[9] The ESWT group reached the study’s recovery endpoint, running 18 minutes consecutively without pain at a fixed intensity, significantly faster: 59.7±25.8 versus 91.6±43.0 days (p=0.008).[9] The authors concluded that adding ESWT to a graded running programme may benefit MTSS patients. Because the two groups came from different hospitals and were not randomised, the study cannot show that ESWT itself caused the faster recovery.[9]
In my practice, I am used to starting with avoiding the aggravating load, sometimes short-term pain relief at the beginning, and physiotherapy from the very start. If a bone stress injury is possible, I am more cautious with anti-inflammatory painkillers. For many of my occupational health and primary care patients this is fairly straightforward: they can rest or take a break, or change their loading profile, for example cycling or doing gym work instead of running.
That said, in my experience changing the loading profile can be difficult for many patients, especially recreational athletes, who often have well-established ways of exercising. Most of my patients do not exercise in any particular way, and those who do tend to exercise in the one way they have always been used to; people who have always run want to keep running. There are cases where switching to something else, such as cycling, works easily, but taking a patient’s own sport away often means that switching requires special effort or adaptability from them. Because of this, many of my patients end up in a cycle: they rest for a while, do some rehabilitation and return to their sport, and I have seen that cycle tend to make the condition chronic.
Getting Back to Running After Shin Splints
A review of conservative treatment describes the return to activity as gradual: over a period of weeks, athletes may slowly increase training intensity and duration as long as they remain pain-free.[4] In the randomized trial above, the end point of the graded running program was being able to run 18 minutes with high intensity.[8]
In runners, a previous history of MTSS was associated with a relative risk of 3.74 for MTSS.[1]
For an elite athlete, the same diagnosis turns the whole training programme upside down. In my experience, many of them simply have to take a break, start rehabilitation, then move gradually through rehabilitation into a new base-training period, and from there progress step by step towards the competition season.
What the Research Doesn’t Tell Us
The treatment evidence for shin splints is thin. In the systematic review, every randomized trial was at high risk of bias,[5] and before 2012 the only three randomized treatment trials had been performed in military populations.[8] On prevention, a 2009 critical review cited two large prospective studies suggesting that neoprene or semi-rigid orthotics may help prevent MTSS,[6] while prior orthotic use was itself associated with MTSS in runners.[1] In that 2013 systematic review, no treatment was supported by trials at low risk of bias.[5]
Conclusion
Shin splints — medial tibial stress syndrome — affects 5%–35% of runners,[1] and a 2009 critical review interprets it as tibial bone resorption that outpaces bone formation.[6] Female sex, increased weight, higher navicular drop, previous running injury and greater hip external rotation were identified as risk factors in a meta-analysis.[2] Clinicians agree well on the diagnosis using history and physical examination,[3] but a concurrent lower leg injury was found in about a third of athletes with MTSS,[3] and further imaging or work-up may be needed to rule out a stress fracture.[4] The literature supports rest as the key acute-phase treatment and a gradual return to activity,[4] while a 2013 systematic review found no therapy supported by trials at low risk of bias.[5] Understanding the condition is the first step toward training that the tibia can keep up with.
This matches what I see in practice: the hardest parts are often telling shin splints apart from a bony stress injury and breaking the cycle of resting and returning to the same sport too early.
References
- https://doi.org/10.2147/OAJSM.S39331
- https://doi.org/10.1177/1941738116673299
- https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2016-097037
- https://doi.org/10.1007/s12178-009-9055-6
- https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-013-0087-0
- https://doi.org/10.2165/00007256-200939070-00002
- https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03262301
- https://doi.org/10.1186/1758-2555-4-12
- https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsm.2010.081992

