Achilles Tendonitis: Why “Tendinopathy” Is the Better Word, and What the Evidence Says About Recovery

Key Takeaways

  • The word “tendonitis” suggests inflammation, but a classic histopathology review found the common overuse tendon conditions to be mainly non-inflammatory and proposed the term tendinopathy instead.[1]
  • In a 2021 systematic review of running injuries, Achilles tendinopathy was among the injuries with the highest incidence proportion, at 10.3%.[2]
  • The 2024 clinical practice guideline states that diagnosis is primarily clinical, and that imaging is not required for it.[3]
  • For people without presumed tendon frailty, the guideline recommends tendon-loading exercise, with loads as high as tolerated, as first-line treatment, and recommends advising that complete rest is not indicated.[3]
  • In a small randomised trial, no statistically significant difference in improvement was found between patients who continued running and jumping within a pain-monitoring model and patients who avoided these activities for the first 6 weeks.[4]
  • A large sham-controlled trial found that a single platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injection did not reduce Achilles tendon dysfunction at 6 months.[5]
  • Recovery is often measured in months rather than weeks, and in a 5-year follow-up, average symptom scores had improved substantially, although fewer than half of patients were completely pain-free.[6]
  • In my practice, a typical patient is a 40- to 50-year-old who plays floorball or padel, sports with a lot of running, quick eccentric loading and changes of direction.
  • In my experience, the tendon often looks normal from the outside and imaging is rarely useful early on. I have found ultrasound helpful when there is clear swelling or I suspect a partial tear.
  • I have seen Achilles tendinitis after fluoroquinolone treatment in my own patients, which has made me personally cautious about prescribing these antibiotics liberally.
  • These days I refer patients to physiotherapy at an early stage. With many of them, I have suggested starting eccentric exercises already before the physiotherapist’s assessment.
  • In my own practice and in my own tendons, the problem often becomes semi-chronic, flaring up when loading exercises are stopped and settling again when they are restarted.

Introduction: Achilles Tendonitis

“Achilles tendonitis” is a common name for Achilles tendon pain, but often a misleading one. The “-itis” ending suggests inflammation. Yet a classic review of tendon histopathology concluded that the common overuse tendon conditions are rarely, if ever, caused by tendinitis, and proposed the umbrella term tendinopathy instead.[1] In my view, this is more than wordplay: if the problem is not primarily inflammatory, treatment aimed only at calming inflammation makes less sense than treatment aimed at the tendon’s capacity to take load.

The condition is common. In a 2021 systematic review of running-related injuries, Achilles tendinopathy accounted for 10.3% of injury incidence and 6.6% of injury prevalence.[2] The 2024 clinical practice guideline cites a prevalence of 4% to 7% for midportion Achilles tendinopathy.[3]

As both a physician and a former competitive athlete, I look at this topic from two angles: what the trials show, and what it takes to keep someone training. This article covers what the condition actually is, how it is diagnosed, what the 2024 guideline recommends, which popular treatments have not held up in trials, and what the long-term course looks like.

In my practice, Achilles tendinopathy is fairly common, and for many patients it is difficult to treat. A fairly typical story is a patient well into adulthood, 40 or 50 years old, who plays floorball or padel, sports with a lot of running, quick eccentric loading and changes of direction, sometimes after a longer break from exercise.

Tendonitis vs. Tendinopathy: What Is Going On Inside the Tendon

The review that pushed the field toward the term tendinopathy described the typical tissue findings as degenerative, with inflammation largely absent, and argued that treatment of athletes with tendinopathies should target this non-inflammatory process.[1]

The guideline also separates two locations that behave differently:

  • Midportion tendinopathy: pain in the body of the tendon, above the heel bone. The 2024 guideline covers this form specifically.[3]
  • Insertional tendinopathy: pain where the tendon attaches to the heel bone. A systematic review on insertional Achilles tendinopathy describes it as a clinical entity distinct from midportion tendinopathy.[7] A later sham-controlled randomised trial of 76 people with insertional tendinopathy, however, found that adding radial shockwave therapy to exercise and education did not improve pain, function or other outcomes compared with sham at 6 or 12 weeks.[12]

This distinction matters because some exercises and treatments studied for one form have not been studied the same way for the other.

In my clinical experience, “Achilles tendonitis” is often used a little inaccurately, because what I usually see is tendinopathy. I do occasionally see a tendon that looks genuinely inflamed, but in my experience that is more often peritendinitis. Part of the reason the word sticks is that the ICD-10 diagnosis I use in my work is itself labelled as inflammation of the Achilles tendon, and there is no separate diagnosis called Achilles tendinopathy. I see the same with golfer’s elbow and tennis elbow: the epicondylitis diagnoses are often used as synonyms for tendinopathy, even though in most cases tendinopathy is what is actually going on.

In my patients, the pain is typically felt 2 to 3 centimetres above the insertion. In many of them the tendon looks completely normal from the outside but hurts when squeezed or when pushing off. Sometimes I see peritendinitis-like swelling, and then it may be fair to talk about a true inflammation in the literal sense. I also see insertional cases where the attachment itself is painful, and sometimes retrocalcaneal bursitis, which can blur the picture. They hurt in slightly different places, and in my experience a skilled clinician can usually tell them apart.

Achilles Tendonitis Risk Factors

According to the 2024 guideline, the cause is likely multifactorial. Modifiable factors that may be useful for patient education include quinolone use, alcohol consumption and ankle plantar flexor strength. In the review the guideline cites, overweight, static foot posture and activity level were not associated with the condition.[3]

Running exposure is a clear theme. The guideline cites a 40% to 52% lifetime cumulative incidence of Achilles tendon injury among runners. That figure refers to Achilles tendon injuries in general, not only tendinopathy.[3]

Fluoroquinolone antibiotics

One medication-related risk deserves its own mention. In a meta-analysis of 15 observational studies, fluoroquinolone treatment was associated with increased odds of Achilles tendinitis (OR 3.95) and Achilles tendon rupture (OR 2.52). The increased risk remained statistically significant in patients aged 60 years or older.[8]

I have seen a few fluoroquinolone adverse effects in my own practice. One patient developed clear Achilles tendinitis after fluoroquinolone treatment. I have not personally seen a rupture. In one patient, the reaction was not limited to the tendon but was a widespread systemic connective tissue inflammation, which was a good reminder to me personally not to prescribe fluoroquinolones as liberally as I sometimes see them prescribed.

How Achilles Tendinopathy Is Diagnosed

The 2024 guideline states that diagnosis is primarily based on clinical examination. Supporting findings include pain provoked by tendon-loading activities, tenderness in the midportion of the tendon, and a positive arc sign and Royal London Hospital test. Tendon thickening supports the diagnosis but may be absent in some people.[3]

Imaging is not required for the diagnosis. The guideline reserves it for diagnostic uncertainty, delayed recovery, worsening symptoms, or before invasive procedures. It also notes that increased tendon thickness is nonspecific, because up to a quarter of adults without symptoms have it.[3] In a 10-year follow-up study, the authors found no ultrasound markers that predicted the long-term outcome.[9]

In my experience, imaging is rarely useful early on. If the tendon looks completely normal from the outside, ultrasound does not necessarily add much to the diagnosis. When there is clear swelling and I suspect a partial tear or something else, I have found ultrasound helpful.

Achilles Tendonitis Treatment: Load, Not Rest

Tendon-loading exercise is first line

The strongest recommendation in the 2024 guideline (Grade A) is that clinicians should use tendon-loading exercise, with loads as high as tolerated, as first-line treatment for people without presumed frailty of the tendon structure. The guideline adds that exercise should be done at least 3 times a week. It no longer restricts clinicians to eccentric exercise only.[3]

That change reflects the trial evidence. In a randomised trial of 58 patients with chronic midportion Achilles tendinopathy, 12 weeks of heavy slow resistance training and 12 weeks of eccentric training were compared. Both groups improved, and the main outcomes did not differ between them. Patient satisfaction tended to be greater with heavy slow resistance after 12 weeks.[10] The drantti.com article on eccentric training for tendinopathy goes deeper into that comparison.

A 2023 living network meta-analysis reached a similar conclusion. Based on low or very low strength of evidence, its authors recommended progressive eccentric or heavy slow resistance exercise for 12 weeks as first-line treatment, and exercise alone for at least 3 months before any add-on treatment is considered.[11] The same analysis found that the limited published evidence on isometric loading for immediate pain relief did not support its use in this context.[11]

I had Achilles tendinopathy myself during my competitive career. It started in a season when I trained harder, sparred more and did a lot of explosive push-offs. Gradually my Achilles tendons became painful, until even walking was difficult. In my case, a foot physiotherapist noticed overpronation, and pronation-support insoles removed the pain almost immediately: stepping and pushing off no longer hurt. Now, about 15 years later, it still flares up from time to time, but not as badly. I clearly notice that my flat-footed biomechanics provoke it, and when I have spent a lot of time without insoles, it starts to come back. When it does, loading exercises, eccentric exercises and heavy slow resistance-type training work best for me.

Complete rest is not the default

The guideline recommends (Grade B) that clinicians advise that complete rest is not indicated, and that people continue activities within pain tolerance.[3]

The best-known trial behind this approach randomised 38 patients. One group continued running and jumping during a tendon-loading programme, guided by a pain-monitoring model. The other group had to avoid these activities for the first 6 weeks. Both groups improved, and the authors could not demonstrate any negative effects from continuing tendon-loading activity.[4]

With some patients, I have suggested trying pronation-support insoles, but I noticed that they did not work for everyone, and they are a sizeable investment, so I now leave that decision to physiotherapists. These days I refer patients to physiotherapy already at an early stage. When the arch is very low and the patient has symptoms, I find a physiotherapist’s analysis of foot biomechanics and arch function particularly useful. With many patients, I have suggested starting eccentric exercises already before the physiotherapist’s assessment, and I do the same exercises myself whenever the pain starts to return.

Education

The guideline also recommends (Grade B) education and counselling on Achilles tendinopathy, focused on either pain science or pathoanatomy, delivered in person or by telehealth.[3]

What Has Not Held Up: Laser, Ultrasound and PRP

Several commonly offered treatments have weak or negative evidence:

  • Low-level laser therapy: the guideline recommends against it for midportion Achilles tendinopathy (Grade C).[3]
  • Therapeutic ultrasound alone: the guideline recommends against it (Grade C).[3]
  • Platelet-rich plasma: in a multicentre, participant-blinded trial of 240 patients, mean VISA-A scores at 6 months were 54.4 after a single PRP injection and 53.4 after a sham injection. The difference was not statistically significant.[5]

Other options are graded more cautiously. The guideline states that clinicians may use heel lifts to temporarily reduce ankle dorsiflexion during activity, and that no recommendation can be made on foot orthoses because the evidence is contradictory.[3]

Corticosteroid injections

Evidence on corticosteroid injections is limited. In a pragmatic Danish cohort treated with controlled exercises plus one or two corticosteroid injections when needed to continue training, the improvement seen at 6 months was maintained at the 10-year follow-up, and 16% had undergone surgery.[9] Because this was a single cohort without a control group, it does not show that injections are better than exercise alone. The 2023 network meta-analysis noted a small theoretical risk of tendon rupture with local corticosteroids, which the authors said should be communicated to patients.[11]

Insertional Achilles Tendinopathy Is a Different Problem

For pain at the heel insertion, a systematic review found that shockwave therapy (ESWT) seemed effective in non-calcified insertional tendinopathy. Eccentric exercise through the full range of motion was associated with low patient satisfaction compared with floor-level eccentric exercise and other conservative options.[7] In the Danish 10-year follow-up, however, insertional tendinopathy did not differ from midportion tendinopathy in any outcome measure after the same treatment protocol of controlled exercise, with corticosteroid injections when needed.[9]

How Long Does Achilles Tendonitis Take to Heal?

The guideline states that most individuals improve, but the extent and timing of recovery vary from person to person.[3]

Long-term data are encouraging, though not perfect. In a 5-year follow-up of patients treated with the Alfredson heel-drop programme, the mean VISA-A score rose from 49.2 at baseline to 83.6. Of these patients, 39.7% were completely pain-free, and 48.3% had received additional treatments along the way.[6] In the Danish cohort, three ruptures occurred 5 to 8 years after the original study.[9]

In my view, this means Achilles tendinopathy is usually a condition measured in months, and some people keep mild symptoms for years.

In my experience, patients who take eccentric exercises seriously generally get help from them. Still, in many patients the problem settles into a semi-chronic state, where it flares up now and then and then stays away again. One difficulty in rehabilitation is that people usually stop the exercises once the pain disappears, and then it returns. That is not necessarily a problem if the pain builds up gradually and the person can adapt each time it starts again, as I do: in normal times I do not need rehabilitation exercises, but whenever the pain worsens, I start them again. Recovery times in my patients are usually long, from weeks to months, and for some, like me, it remains semi-chronic for years.

Conclusion

“Achilles tendonitis” is usually Achilles tendinopathy, a mainly non-inflammatory overuse condition.[1] It is among the most common running injuries.[2] The 2024 guideline recommends a clinical diagnosis, tendon-loading exercise with loads as high as tolerated as first-line treatment, education, and advice that complete rest is not indicated.[3] In a small randomised trial, no negative effects could be demonstrated from continuing sport within a pain-monitoring model.[4] Heavy slow resistance and eccentric programmes did not differ in their clinical and structural outcomes in one trial.[10] PRP did not beat a sham injection.[5] Recovery takes patience: long-term follow-up shows substantial average improvement, but mild symptoms may remain.[6]

This matches what I see in practice: I see this most often in middle-aged adults returning to fast, change-of-direction sports, and I am used to referring patients to physiotherapy early rather than relying on imaging. In my experience, patients who take eccentric exercises seriously generally get help from them, but the condition often flares up again after rehabilitation stops, so in my view it is more something to manage over time than a one-off injury. My own Achilles tendons have followed the same pattern for about 15 years: they stay calm in normal times, and when the pain returns, I go back to loading, eccentric and heavy slow resistance exercises.

References

  1. https://doi.org/10.2165/00007256-199927060-00004
  2. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jshs.2021.04.001
  3. https://doi.org/10.2519/jospt.2024.0302
  4. https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546506298279
  5. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2021.6986
  6. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2011-090035
  7. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-012-2219-8
  8. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00228-019-02713-1
  9. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjsem-2018-000415
  10. https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546515584760
  11. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37553459/
  12. https://doi.org/10.1177/02692155241295683

Similar Posts